When Concern Becomes a Call to Remove Technology From Classrooms - Some Thoughts


Caveat: While we are not licensed teachers, our work has taken us into more than 1,000 schools and brought us into ongoing conversations with educators across Canada. Through those discussions, we have heard perspectives on classroom technology that deserve a place in the public conversation. Much like the debate surrounding social media, the discussion about technology in classrooms has become increasingly political and polarized. Some teachers have told us they are becoming cautious about sharing their views publicly because of the intensity of the debate. With this article, we hope to bring some of those perspectives and concerns to parents, caregivers, and fellow educators that is not necessarily taking place in the public discourse on social media platforms. We want to make it clear that we do not speak for all teachers. Our aim is to give space to voices that may otherwise go unheard and encourage a more thoughtful discussion about when, why, and how technology should be used in classrooms.
A student distracted by a laptop. A teacher struggling to compete with notifications. A parent or caregiver wondering whether another online assignment is helping their child learn, all these concerns deserve a thoughtful response. Questioning the push to remove technology from classrooms does not require us to dismiss the problems that helped drive that push.
However, there is a difference between recognizing a problem and establishing that the proposed solution will address it. When legitimate concerns grow into a broad belief that technology itself is undermining education, we need to examine how we reached that conclusion. When the debate about tech in classrooms narrows to a single explanation, it shapes what we pay attention to and what we overlook. That’s how a distorted debate can distract us from other factors that deserve scrutiny.
Educator Lee Parkinson, known online as Mr P, raises a relevant point in the caption accompanying his Instagram video, “not all screen time is equal!” He also challenges the assumption that concerns about young people’s screen use necessarily describe what is happening in schools (1).
That distinction matters. Before we decide that removing classroom technology is the answer, we need to establish which uses are causing problems, how widespread those uses are, and whether the proposed changes will improve learning. The word “screen” tells us what a child is looking at, however, it tells us very little about what that child is doing, thinking, or learning.
When Different Activities Become One Problem
In the classroom debate, “technology” can become one broad label for very different things. A personal smartphone delivering social media notifications is different from a school laptop used for a guided writing exercise. A student watching unrelated videos is doing something different from a student using text-to-speech to access a lesson. An educational platform that collects unnecessary information raises different questions from a digital microscope.
Likewise, watching an explanation, creating a presentation, practising a skill, and asking AI to complete an assignment should not be treated as equivalent educational experiences. Each involves technology, but the student’s participation and opportunities to learn can differ considerably.
We explored this distinction in our article, “Beyond Screen Time: What New Classroom Research Tells Us About Technology, AI, Learning, and Digital Self-Regulation” (2). Our discussion of Australian classroom research emphasized the importance of examining activities, teaching practices, and learning objectives rather than relying on screen-time totals alone. Classroom observation also provides an opportunity to check whether public perceptions reflect what students and teachers are actually doing.
Parkinson’s point helps identify a weakness in the broader debate. When we group different activities together, we lose the distinctions needed to make sound educational decisions. We stop asking which tools support learning, under what conditions, and for which students. Instead, we begin asking whether technology belongs in schools at all.
We also need to distinguish concerns about children’s overall digital lives from evidence about classroom practice. Recreational use at home, personal phone use during a lesson, and a teacher directed activity are different contexts. Findings from one can raise useful questions about another, but we still need to establish whether those findings apply.
Our article, “YouTube in Our Classrooms: When Headlines, Data, and Research Tell Different Parts of the Same Story”, makes a related distinction (3). A teacher showing a selected instructional video, a student independently browsing YouTube, and a school providing laptops for educational work involve separate policy decisions. Evidence of recreational viewing deserves attention, but it does not automatically answer whether laptops should remain available for other learning activities.
A Real Concern Can Lead To An Overly Broad Conclusion
This is where the concept of a “moral panic” can be useful, provided we use the term carefully. Calling something a moral panic should never become a way to silence parents, caregivers, or educators who have experienced real difficulties. There are legitimate reasons to question classroom technology. The issue is whether the public response has become broader, more certain, or more sweeping than the evidence justifies.
A moral panic does not need to begin with an invented problem. It can grow around something real. A troubling experience receives attention, becomes a symbol of a larger concern, and eventually gets treated as proof that an entire category of activity or technology is harmful. Along the way, distinctions that matter can disappear.
In, “When Populism Turns on Science: Lived Experience vs Research — Bridging the Gap”, we discussed why personal observations deserve respect while still requiring careful interpretation (4). Seeing a student struggle with distraction establishes a reason to investigate. It does not, by itself, establish the cause, how widespread the problem is, or which intervention will work. We also cautioned against accepting research readily when it supports our beliefs while dismissing findings that complicate them.
The OECD’s PISA 2022 findings illustrate why this matters. Approximately 30% of students across OECD countries reported being distracted by digital devices in most or every mathematics lesson. About 25% reported being distracted by other students’ device use. These findings identify a classroom concern that schools should address (5).
However, when these findings are presented as proof that technology is “making children less intelligent,” or as justification for removing all classroom technology, the conclusion extends beyond what the research establishes. PISA identifies relationships between device use and achievement. It does not, on its own, prove that devices caused lower performance, demonstrate a decline in intelligence, or establish that blanket removal would improve learning.
There is also another part of the evidence that needs to remain in the conversation. The same PISA research found that moderate use of digital devices for learning at school was associated with higher mathematics performance than no use, including after accounting for students’ and schools’ socioeconomic circumstances. That finding does not prove that moderate technology use caused better results either. However, it complicates the claim that classroom technology is inherently harmful (6).
Selecting the findings about distraction while leaving out those about moderate educational use gives parents and caregivers an incomplete picture. A real concern can then become the basis for a much broader story, devices distract students, therefore classroom technology undermines learning, therefore schools should remove it. Each step requires evidence. The first finding does not automatically establish the final conclusion, although some would like parents and caregivers to believe it does.
This selective presentation can contribute to a moral panic, whether or not that is the intention of the person sharing it. Recognizing this process does not mean everyone advocating less classroom technology is participating in a moral panic. It means we should examine whether a particular recommendation matches the evidence being used to support it.
Consider a classroom where students regularly drift away from an assignment to browse unrelated websites. Is the device needed for the task? Are expectations clear? Would paper serve the learning objective better? Have students been taught how to manage distractions? Removing devices might be appropriate for that lesson. Changing the activity, limiting particular functions, or establishing periods when screens are closed might also be appropriate. The response should follow an assessment of the problem. The PISA findings support taking distraction seriously and examining how devices are used. They do not establish that removing all classroom technology will improve education.
“Educational” Is A Claim That Deserves Examination
Recognizing that not all screen time is equal does not give schools or technology companies a free pass. Calling a product “educational” does not establish that it helps students learn. Parents and caregivers are entitled to ask whether schools adopted some technologies before developing a clear plan for using them. Purchasing devices is a different task from preparing educators to teach effectively with them.
In, Schools Should Be Prepared For Classroom Tech Pushback From Some Parents & Caregivers This New School Year, we argued that schools should explain what a digital tool contributes to a particular learning experience (7). Its educational purpose, alternatives, accessibility benefits, privacy implications, and observable outcomes should all be open to examination. Families deserve clear answers about these decisions.
If a worksheet simply moves from paper to a screen, families can reasonably ask what students gained. There may be a useful reason, such as an accessibility feature or timely feedback, but the reason should be clear. If a platform creates more distraction or privacy concerns than educational value, schools should reconsider it.
If an activity works better through discussion, handwriting, physical materials, or direct instruction, there should be no pressure to add a device. Supporting thoughtful an intentional technology use includes being willing to use less of it. Schools should also explain what information a tool collects, why that collection is necessary, and who can access it. “We need to prepare students for the future” is too vague to justify every digital purchase or classroom activity.
Educators Need Preparation and Support
Expecting educators to make these decisions means giving them time, training, and support. A device rollout cannot substitute for professional learning about when a tool helps, when it interferes, and how to assess whether students are learning. Teachers need opportunities to consider practical questions.
When would printed reading be preferable?
When could a digital resource make a concept easier to understand?
How can students demonstrate their understanding without relying on the tool that helped them practise?
Our article, The Emerging AI Literacy Divide: Are We Creating Two Different Educational Futures for Our Children?, examines the role of training and institutional support in preparing educators for AI (8). Knowing how to generate teaching materials is different from knowing how to teach students to question AI outputs, protect information, and avoid outsourcing the thinking an assignment is intended to develop. These are pedagogy teaching decisions, and they require more than knowing how to operate a device or sign into a platform.
Here at The White Hatter, our experience presenting to schools has reinforced the importance of intentional use. Putting technology into a classroom does not automatically improve education. Educators need preparation to connect its use to a learning objective and the confidence to put it away when another approach would serve students better. School districts share responsibility for providing that preparation. Approving or purchasing a product should come with support for evaluating and using it appropriately.
What Might Disappear With A Blanket Removal?
A broad removal policy also needs to account for the different ways students access education. Some students use digital tools to read text aloud, enlarge print, communicate, translate unfamiliar language, or organize their ideas. Decisions about classroom technology need to consider these uses from the outset. A device that creates an avoidable distraction for one student may provide essential access to a lesson for another. A useful policy needs to account for both circumstances.
There is also an educational question about preparation. Students encounter digital information, persuasive design, online claims, and AI generated material beyond school. We believe that schools have a role in helping them learn how to evaluate and navigate that environment. This does not mean students need constant access to devices. Digital literacy can include discussion, reflection, and activities completed without a screen. It does mean that removing technology should come with a clear explanation of how students will still develop the knowledge and practical skills they need in today’s onlife world.
Learning when to close a laptop matters. So does learning how to use one with purpose, recognize an unreliable source, protect personal information, and explain the reasoning behind an answer.
What Parents and Caregivers Should Ask
Families can ask specific questions that move the conversation beyond whether screens are simply good or bad:
What is my child doing with this technology, and what are they expected to learn?
Why is this tool suitable for the activity?
Would another approach serve the learning objective better?
When are students expected to work without screens?
How are distraction and off-task behaviour addressed?
What training and support do educators receive?
What information does the tool collect?
How will the school assess what students can do independently?
How will changes affect students who rely on accessibility tools?
Does the research supporting a proposed policy examine comparable devices, activities, and students?
These questions create room for accountability and improvement. They also give schools something useful to respond to, a request to explain and assess actual practice.
The push to remove technology from classrooms may reflect frustration with choices that deserve scrutiny, and we should listen to that frustration. However, concern about young people’s screen use should not become an assumption that every classroom use contributes to the same problem. Research and evidence should help us make those distinctions. Its limitations and findings should remain visible even when they complicate the argument we favour.
Parkinson’s reminder that not all screen time is equal offers a useful starting point. From there, we need to examine the activity, the teaching, the student’s needs, and the learning that follows.
Our goal should be classrooms where tools earn their place through a clear educational purpose, teachers have the support to use them well, and students have regular opportunities to learn both with and without them. Remember, When the debate about tech in classrooms narrows to a single explanation, it shapes what we pay attention to and what we overlook. That’s how a distorted debate can distract us from other factors that deserve scrutiny.
Concern should prompt careful examination. The decisions that follow should be specific enough to address the problem we actually have.
Digital Food For Thought
The White Hatter
Facts Not Fear, Facts Not Emotions, Enlighten Not Frighten, Know Tech Not No Tech
References














