The Power Of Influence: Helping Our Kids Find Their Own Voice in a Digital World That Constantly Tells Them Who They Should Be


There was a time when young people primarily compared themselves to those around them. Their classmates, teammates, friends, and perhaps the occasional celebrity on television or in a magazine helped shape their understanding of what was popular, attractive, successful, or socially acceptable. Those comparisons could certainly be difficult, but they were generally limited by geography, social circles, and the media available at the time.
Today, that comparison has become almost limitless. A youth or teen can open a social media app and, within minutes, encounter hundreds of carefully selected images and videos of people who appear more attractive, more successful, more popular, more talented, or simply happier than they are. They see bedrooms that look better than theirs, bodies that appear more desirable, friendships that seem more exciting, vacations they cannot afford, and lifestyles that may feel completely out of reach.
What they often don't see is everything happening outside the camera's frame. They don't see the dozens of photographs that were rejected before the perfect one was posted. They don't see the filters, lighting, editing, or increasingly sophisticated AI tools used to alter appearances. They don't see the arguments that happened before the smiling family photograph, the loneliness behind the seemingly perfect social life, or the financial pressures that might accompany the expensive lifestyle being displayed.
Social media can present a thousand versions of a life that appears better than your own, without showing you the full reality behind any of them.
Here at The White Hatter, we believe this is an important conversation that parents, caregivers, and educators should be having with young people. Not because social media is inherently harmful, or because every youth or teen who uses it will struggle with self-esteem, but because comparison, belonging, identity, and acceptance are powerful developmental influences that existed long before smartphones arrived.
In our previous articles, “Social Comparison and Body Image” (1) and “Teenagers and Social Comparison: Coping Strategies for Parents & Caregivers in the Onlife World” (2), we explored how the curated nature of social media can influence how young people perceive their appearance, achievements, and social standing. We also emphasized that social comparison is not unique to digital technology. It is a normal part of human development, particularly during adolescence, when peer acceptance and identity formation become increasingly important. Technology hasn't invented these pressures. However, it can amplify them, accelerate them, and make them harder to escape.
The Pressure to Become Someone Else
Adolescence has always been a time of discovering who we are, what we believe, where we belong, and how we want others to see us. Experimenting with appearance, clothing, music, interests, and friendships is a normal and often healthy part of growing up. The challenge emerges when exploration begins to feel less like a choice and more like an obligation.
A teen might genuinely enjoy a particular style of clothing, only to abandon it because someone online calls it embarrassing. Another might stop sharing their artwork because a stranger criticizes their ability. A young person might change how they speak, dress, or express themselves because the people receiving the most attention online appear to behave differently.
Sometimes this pressure comes from direct criticism. Other times, it comes from watching which appearances, opinions, and behaviours receive the most likes, comments, shares, and attention. Over time, a young person may begin asking themselves a troubling question, "Who do I need to become for other people to accept me?” That question is very different from asking, "Who am I becoming, and what kind of person do I want to be?” One is driven primarily by external approval. The other creates space for personal growth, reflection, values, and identity.
Of course, wanting acceptance is not a weakness. Belonging is a fundamental human need, especially during adolescence. Young people naturally look to their peers for feedback and reassurance as they develop a stronger sense of self. However, there is an important difference between learning from others and allowing others to determine your worth.
This is something we also explored in our resource “Mental Health, Social Comparison, and the Need to Belong” (3), where we discussed why online comparison can feel particularly intense for young people and why the relationship between technology and mental health is far more complex than simply blaming screens. A young person's existing vulnerabilities, relationships, environment, and sense of belonging all matter when considering how online experiences may affect them.
When the Algorithm Becomes a Mirror
One of the more subtle influences of social media is that young people are not simply comparing themselves with their friends. They may also be comparing themselves with content selected and repeatedly presented by recommendation systems. These systems are generally designed to predict what will keep someone engaged, not necessarily what will support their developing sense of identity or self-worth.
If a teen begins watching videos about appearance, fitness, fashion, popularity, or personal success, the platform may recommend more content on those same subjects. Depending on the platform and how the teen interacts with it, this can create a repetitive environment in which certain appearances, lifestyles, or expectations seem far more common than they actually are.
A young person who initially watches a few videos about improving their appearance might eventually encounter increasingly narrow or unrealistic beauty standards. Someone interested in fitness could find themselves surrounded by highly muscular bodies and messages suggesting that their current appearance is inadequate.
One example we have written about extensively is a social media trend known as "looksmaxxing." In our article, “Looksmaxxing: The Growing Pressure on Teen Boys to "Optimize" Their Appearance” (4), we examined how some online communities encourage teenage boys to evaluate and modify their physical appearance according to increasingly narrow standards of attractiveness.
There is nothing inherently wrong with wanting to improve one's appearance, become physically fit, or develop healthy personal grooming habits. The concern emerges when ordinary self improvement becomes an ongoing pursuit of perceived physical perfection, particularly when young people begin measuring themselves against unrealistic standards promoted by influencers and online communities. The message can gradually shift from "Here is something you might enjoy learning or improving" to "You are not good enough until you look, act, or live this way."
We should also recognize that social media experiences vary considerably. Some youth find supportive communities, discover new interests, develop meaningful friendships, and gain confidence by connecting with others who share their experiences. For young people who feel isolated in their immediate surroundings, online communities can provide a valuable sense of belonging.
This is why we believe the conversation needs to move beyond simply measuring screen time or declaring social media good or bad. We need to examine what young people are experiencing, how they interpret those experiences, and whether their online interactions are helping them develop a stronger sense of self or encouraging them to constantly question their worth.
Don't Let Someone Else Retune Your Strings
Recently, we watched Eric Church's 2026 commencement address at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. His message about individuality, authenticity, and the importance of staying true to who you are resonated with us and became the inspiration for this article (5).
Church used the six strings of a guitar to illustrate important values that help shape our lives, including family, relationships, community, resilience, and individuality. One of the messages that particularly stood out to us was his warning about allowing outside pressures to influence who we become. The metaphor of not allowing someone else to retune your strings captures this challenge particularly well.
Imagine that every person is a musical instrument, with their own sound, tone, and character. Throughout life, we learn how to play that instrument. We develop skills, discover strengths, recognize weaknesses, and sometimes make adjustments as we grow. Other people can help us learn. A good teacher, mentor, friend, parent, or caregiver might encourage us to practise, improve, and discover abilities we didn't know we had, and that is healthy guidance.
However, imagine someone walking up to your instrument and insisting that your strings need to be tightened or loosened because they don't like the sound you make. Another person comes along and demands a different adjustment. Then someone else insists you should sound more like the instrument beside you.
Eventually, if you allow everyone else to make those adjustments, you may no longer recognize your own sound. This is what can happen when young people begin allowing every comment, criticism, trend, or social expectation to influence how they see themselves. There is a difference between allowing someone to help you become a better version of yourself and allowing someone to convince you that being yourself is not good enough.
This doesn't mean young people should ignore constructive criticism, reject accountability, or refuse to change. Personal growth often requires listening to perspectives that challenge our thinking and behaviour. If someone points out that our words have hurt another person, that feedback deserves consideration. If a teacher identifies an area where we can improve, that guidance may be valuable. If a trusted friend raises a concern about our choices, listening could help us make a better decision. However, an anonymous stranger's insult, a cruel comment about appearance, or a trend suggesting everyone must look or behave a certain way does not deserve the same influence.
One of the most valuable digital literacy skills we can teach young people is learning to distinguish between feedback that helps them grow and criticism that simply attempts to diminish them. Not everyone who has an opinion about you deserves a vote in who you become.
Popularity Is Not the Same as Personal Worth
One of the challenges of growing up in today's onlife world, where the online and offline parts of life increasingly overlap, is that social approval can become visible and measurable. Likes, views, followers, comments, and shares can create the impression that popularity is an objective measure of value.
A photograph that receives hundreds of likes might feel more meaningful than one that receives only a handful. A video that attracts thousands of views may appear to validate someone's appearance, personality, or opinions. For some young people, the absence of engagement can feel like rejection, even when no rejection was intended.
However, these numbers tell us very little about someone's character, integrity, kindness, intelligence, creativity, or potential. A person can have thousands of followers and still feel lonely. Someone can receive very little attention online while having strong friendships, meaningful relationships, and a healthy sense of self-worth. The number of people watching your life is not necessarily a measure of how meaningful that life is. We believe this distinction is especially important because many platforms make public attention highly visible. Young people can begin confusing being noticed with being valued.
In our article, “From Social Media, to Social AI, to Real Life: Are Youth and Teens Redefining What It Means to Be Connected?” (6), we shared observations from our conversations with students suggesting that some youth and teens may be placing greater value on smaller social circles, authentic relationships, and experiences that do not require public attention or validation. We were careful to acknowledge that these observations are anecdotal and should not be interpreted as evidence of a universal shift among young people. However, they raise an interesting question, “Are some teens beginning to recognize that meaningful relationships and personal experiences can matter more than the size of their online audience?” We believe this is a conversation worth having.
Parents, caregivers, and educators can help challenge the idea that popularity determines worth by reinforcing qualities that are not easily measured by a digital counter. Compassion, honesty, resilience, curiosity, courage, reliability, and the ability to treat others with dignity are all qualities that matter, even when nobody is watching or clicking a like button, something that we like to call the Human Factor (7). Some of the most meaningful contributions a young person will ever make may receive no online recognition whatsoever.
AI Is Adding Another Layer to the Comparison
Generative artificial intelligence is creating an additional challenge that deserves attention. Young people are increasingly encountering images, videos, and digital personalities that may not represent real people or authentic experiences. AI generated influencers can display appearances that are digitally constructed. Editing tools can alter facial features, body proportions, skin texture, clothing, and backgrounds with very little effort. Videos can depict lifestyles, relationships, and experiences that never actually occurred. This means a young person may now be comparing themselves not only with carefully curated versions of real people, but also with appearances and experiences that are entirely synthetic.
In our article, “When Beauty Is No Longer Human: Social AI, Teens, and the New Comparison Trap” (8), we examined this emerging challenge. Traditional social media has long presented carefully curated images of real people. Social AI introduces something different, that being digitally generated appearances that are not limited by the realities of human development, aging, genetics, or physical characteristics. A digitally created influencer does not need to experience acne, puberty, physical imperfections, or the natural changes that occur as the human body develops.
For a young person who does not understand how these images are created, the comparison can become particularly unfair. Imagine a 13 year old looking at a digitally created face and wondering why their own skin, hair, or facial features don't look the same. They may be measuring themselves against something that never existed in the physical world.
We should be careful not to suggest that every edited photograph or AI generated image is harmful. Digital creativity can be entertaining, artistic, and empowering. However, problems can emerge when young people interpret these representations as realistic standards they should be trying to achieve.
This is why AI literacy and media literacy must become part of the same conversation. Young people need to understand not only that images can be edited, but also that something can look completely authentic while being partly or entirely artificial. We are entering a period where young people may increasingly compare their very real human imperfections with digitally generated versions of perfection that were never human in the first place. Helping them recognize that difference is not about creating fear of technology. It is about giving them the knowledge and confidence to question what they see rather than automatically measuring themselves against it.
We Can't Build Confidence by Removing Every Uncomfortable Experience
As parents and caregivers, our natural instinct is often to protect our children from criticism, rejection, embarrassment, and disappointment. That instinct comes from a place of care. However, helping young people develop a strong sense of identity requires more than protecting them from every negative opinion or uncomfortable interaction.
At some point, our kids will encounter someone who doesn't like their appearance, disagrees with their beliefs, criticizes their abilities, or excludes them from a social group. These experiences existed long before the internet and will continue to exist regardless of which technologies we allow our children to use. Our responsibility is not to guarantee that nobody will ever criticize them. That is neither possible nor necessarily helpful. Instead, we need to help them develop the emotional skills to recognize when criticism is worth considering, when it should be challenged, and when it deserves no further attention.
This is closely connected to a concept we explored in our article, “The Gift of Friction: Why Parents and Caregivers Need to Stop Bubble Wrapping Childhood” (9). In that article, we discussed the importance of distinguishing between discomfort and genuine harm. Disappointment, frustration, disagreement, and manageable setbacks can provide opportunities for young people to develop emotional regulation, problem solving skills, resilience, and confidence, particularly when supportive adults are available to guide them.
However, we also emphasized that not all adversity is beneficial. Bullying, abuse, discrimination, exploitation, and sustained emotional distress should never be dismissed as experiences children simply need to endure to become stronger, and that distinction is especially important in the digital world.
A teen receiving a respectful disagreement about something they posted is not necessarily experiencing harm. A young person being repeatedly targeted, threatened, humiliated, or harassed online is facing a very different situation that may require adult intervention, and we should not confuse the two.
The goal is not to make our children immune to what others think. It is to help them develop enough confidence and perspective that someone else's opinion does not automatically become their own truth. We cannot prevent every person from criticizing our children, but we can help our children learn that criticism does not automatically define who they are.
What Parents, Caregivers, and Educators Can Do
At The White Hatter, we often speak about the importance of connection, character, capability, confidence, and independence when helping young people navigate technology. These five foundations are especially relevant when discussing identity and social comparison. They are also explored in greater detail in our article, “The Gift of Friction” (10).
Connection means creating relationships in which young people feel accepted and valued beyond their achievements, appearance, popularity, or online presence. When children know they have trusted adults who will listen without immediately judging, they are more likely to share experiences that make them question themselves.
Character involves helping young people develop values that are not dependent on public approval. Kindness, empathy, honesty, integrity, and accountability should matter more than the number of likes a post receives. We should also encourage young people to consider how their own comments may influence someone else's sense of self-worth.
Capability means teaching practical digital literacy skills. Young people should understand how recommendation systems influence what they see, how photographs and videos can be manipulated, how online popularity metrics work, and how to recognize unrealistic or misleading representations. They also need strategies for managing unwanted interactions, including blocking, reporting, adjusting privacy settings, and seeking help.
Confidence grows when young people are given opportunities to make age appropriate decisions, develop interests, experience manageable setbacks, and discover what they are capable of accomplishing. Confidence should not depend entirely on being praised. It should also come from knowing they can learn, improve, recover from mistakes, and make decisions consistent with their values.
Independence develops when parents and caregivers gradually allow young people greater responsibility as they demonstrate readiness. Our goal should not be to control every online experience indefinitely, but to prepare young people to navigate those experiences thoughtfully when we are no longer looking over their shoulders.
These foundations are not limited to technology. They are life skills that become especially important in a digital environment where feedback, comparison, and social influence can be constant.
Conversations Worth Having With Our Kids
One of the most effective things parents, caregivers, and educators can do is move beyond warnings about the dangers of social media and begin asking questions that encourage young people to reflect on their experiences.
In our previous article on teenagers and social comparison, we discussed the importance of helping young people develop awareness of how social media content affects their emotions and self perception. Rather than immediately criticizing the influencers or content creators a teen follows, we might ask:
"How do you feel about yourself after watching that person's content?"
"Do you think what we're seeing represents their everyday life, or just the parts they've chosen to share?"
"Have you ever felt pressure to change something about yourself because of what you saw online?"
"What qualities do you admire in someone that have nothing to do with how they look or how popular they are?"
"If someone you didn't know criticized something you really enjoyed doing, how much importance would you give their opinion?"
"How would you know whether someone's criticism was meant to help you improve or simply make you feel bad?"
These questions are not intended to interrogate young people or force them into agreeing with an adult's perspective. They are opportunities to develop critical thinking, emotional awareness, and a healthier relationship with online feedback.
Sometimes the most valuable conversation begins when a parent or caregiver shares their own experiences. Adults are not immune to social comparison. We also encounter carefully curated lifestyles, professional achievements, financial success stories, and images that can make us question whether we are doing enough or measuring up. Acknowledging this can help young people understand that comparison is a human experience, not a personal failure.
It also gives us an opportunity to model how we respond. If we constantly criticize our own appearance, compare our possessions with those of others, or measure our success against what we see online, our children may absorb those attitudes even when our verbal advice tells them something different. Remember, young people are often influenced as much by how we live our values as by how we explain them.
The Difference Between Fitting In and Belonging
There is another distinction we believe deserves more attention, fitting in and belonging are not necessarily the same thing. Fitting in can sometimes require changing parts of ourselves to gain acceptance from a particular group. We may adjust our clothing, opinions, interests, or behaviour because we fear being excluded. Belonging, on the other hand, involves feeling accepted and respected without having to abandon the qualities that make us who we are.
Of course, healthy relationships require compromise, consideration, and personal growth. Authenticity is not permission to disregard other people's feelings or refuse accountability. However, young people should not feel that acceptance requires them to constantly hide their interests, suppress their personalities, or pretend to be someone they are not. This is particularly important for youth who feel different from their peers.
For some, the internet provides opportunities to connect with people who share interests or experiences that may not be represented in their immediate school or community. A young person who loves an unusual hobby, has a particular creative talent, or feels socially isolated may discover online communities where those qualities are appreciated. That is one of the genuine opportunities technology can provide.
In our article examining the possible shift from public social media toward smaller digital communities and renewed interest in real life relationships, we discussed how the quality of our connections can matter far more than the quantity (11). A young person can have hundreds of online contacts without feeling genuinely connected. Another might have only a handful of close friends but experience a strong sense of belonging, trust, and acceptance. Those meaningful relationships can exist both online and offline. The internet can help young people find communities, maintain friendships across distances, and participate in shared interests that might otherwise be inaccessible.
Our goal as parents, caregivers, and educators should be to help young people recognize the difference between communities that encourage them to grow and communities that demand they conform. A healthy friendship, whether online or offline, should leave room for individuality.
Your Child Is Still Becoming Who They Are
One last thought from us here at The White Hatter. When we encourage young people to be themselves, we need to remember that adolescence is a period of change. A 12 year old does not need to have a fully developed identity, fixed set of beliefs, or a lifelong passion, they are still learning. Their interests may change, their opinions may evolve, and they may experiment with different styles, friendships, and ways of expressing themselves. That is not necessarily evidence that social media is changing them for the worse, sometimes it is simply part of growing up.
The objective should not be to preserve a child's identity exactly as it exists today. It should be to provide enough support, guidance, and freedom for that identity to develop without being dominated by fear of rejection or pressure for approval. We want our children to remain open to new ideas, learn from others, and become better versions of themselves. What we don't want is for them to believe that their value depends on becoming a copy of someone else.
There will always be people who have opinions about how our children should look, dress, speak, behave, or live. Some of those opinions will be thoughtful and helpful. Others will be careless, cruel, or driven by someone else's insecurities and expectations. Social media can amplify those voices and make them louder and more numerous. Algorithms can repeatedly expose young people to narrow definitions of beauty, popularity, success, and happiness. AI can now create convincing representations of lives and appearances that may never have existed. However, none of these influences should have the final say in determining a young person's worth.
As parents, caregivers, and educators, we have an opportunity to remind young people that they do not have to earn their value through likes, followers, appearance, or public approval. They are allowed to be different, they are allowed to have interests that aren't popular, they are allowed to make mistakes, change their minds, and grow, they are allowed to listen to constructive criticism without accepting every negative opinion as truth, and most importantly, they are allowed to become themselves rather than spending their lives trying to become someone else. Perhaps this is the message we should be sharing with every young person growing up in today's onlife world.
To summarize the message that inspired us from Eric Church's 2026 commencement address:
Social media will show you thousands of lives that appear better than yours. Some will be carefully curated, some will be digitally altered, and some may not be real at all. There will be people who criticize your appearance, question your abilities, or suggest that you need to change to earn their approval. Listen to those who genuinely want to help you grow, but don't give everyone permission to retune your strings. You have your own sound, your own perspective, your own strengths, and your own contribution to make. You don't need to be perfect, and you don't need to have everything figured out. You just need the freedom and confidence to discover who you are becoming. “Because the world doesn't need another cover song. It needs an original.”
Digital Food For Thought
The White Hatter
Facts Not Fear, Facts Not Emotions, Enlighten Not Frighten, Know Tech Not No Tech
References














