Is the Phone Really to Blame? Understanding Teen Withdrawal and Parent/Child Relationships

Many parents and caregivers share the same story, “I gave them a phone a year ago and we had this lovely relationship, they were a great kid, and now they don’t want to talk to me and they’re terrible.” It can feel like the phone flipped a switch and turned your once open child into a stranger. But, the truth is often less about technology and more about biology and development, pulling away from parents is a natural part of adolescence.

It’s not new for parents to look for something to blame when faced with this stage of development. For example in past generations of parenting:

• Comic books (1940s–1950s): Parents and experts feared that comics would rot children’s brains, encourage delinquency, and desensitize them to violence. In 1954, Dr. Fredric Wertham’s book Seduction of the Innocent even led to U.S. Senate hearings on the dangers of comic books.

• Rock ‘n’ roll music (1950s–1960s): Elvis Presley’s hip movements and the Beatles hair cuts were considered scandalous, and parents worried rock music would corrupt morals and encourage rebellion.

• Television (1960s–1970s): Concerns ranged from kids becoming “zombies” staring at the screen to fears TV would destroy family conversations and reading habits.

• Video games (1980s–1990s): Titles like Mortal Kombat and Doom were accused of encouraging violence, addiction, and social withdrawal.

• Texting and instant messaging (1990s–2000s): Parents worried that abbreviations like LOL or BRB would erode grammar and that kids were “losing the art of real conversation.”

Adolescence is a stage marked by change. As children move into their teenage years, their brains and bodies undergo profound transformations. One of the most important shifts is the natural pull toward independence. Teens begin to withdraw from their parents, not because they’ve stopped loving them or because of phones, but because separating is part of forming their own identity.

Psychologists and counsellors call this “individuation”. It’s a healthy process. where teens start testing boundaries, seeking privacy, and turning to peers more often. This isn’t a rejection of family, it’s practice for adulthood.

Today, the timing often makes technology, the internet, and social media look like the culprit. A youth or teen receives a phone, and around the same time, they begin to pull away. The coincidence is powerful, but correlation doesn’t equal causation. The phone may provide a new outlet for connection, but it isn’t responsible for the underlying developmental drive to grow more independent.

That’s not to say phones don’t complicate things. They can intensify peer connections, create new sources of stress, or become tools of avoidance. However, they don’t fundamentally change the fact that a young teen is wired to seek space from mom and dad.

While parents and caregivers can’t, and shouldn’t, stop the natural process of teens pulling away, there are ways to reshape how you stay connected during these years such as:

Shift the relationship, don’t fight it.

The closeness you shared when your child was younger will not look the same in adolescence, and that’s okay. Rather than trying to hold on to what once was, focus on creating new forms of connection. This might mean watching a show together, sharing a meal without distractions, or even bonding over humour. Sometimes, the most powerful form of support is simply being present and available when your teen needs you, rather than being your device all the time, even if they don’t say much in return.

Stay interested without interrogating.

Adolescents often retreat when every conversation feels like a cross examination. Asking rapid fire questions about their day or their friends can make them clam up. Instead, approach with curiosity and openness. Show interest in what matters to them, whether it’s a favorite video game, a new hobby, or their favorite music. At the same time, respect when they signal “not now.” By honouring those boundaries, you build trust and show that you value their growing independence.

Use technology as a bridge.

Although phones can sometimes feel like a barrier, they can also serve as a valuable tool for connection. A funny meme, a supportive text message, or even joining your teen in an online game can provide shared experiences that strengthen your relationship. Meeting them in their digital spaces demonstrates flexibility and a willingness to understand their world, which can go a long way in keeping communication open.

Hold boundaries with love.

Granting independence doesn’t mean letting go of all structure. Adolescents still need clear expectations around technology, the internet, social media, respect, and family commitments. What makes the difference is how those rules are communicated and enforced. When boundaries are set with calmness, consistency, and empathy rather than frustration or blame, teens are more likely to respect them. This approach helps preserve your authority while reinforcing that limits exist because you care about their well-being.

If you notice withdrawal, it doesn’t mean your child is broken or that you’ve failed. It also doesn’t mean the phone “ruined” your relationship. It’s more accurate to see this as a stage of development. By recognizing it as normal, parents can let go of unnecessary guilt and focus on building a new, evolving relationship. However, we also recognize that technology can be problematic for “some” youth, but not the majority.

It’s tempting to point to technology as the cause of every challenge. However, teenagers have been rolling their eyes, closing their doors, and leaning on friends for generations. Technology might spotlight the change, but it isn’t necessarily the driver in all cases. However, sometimes it can amplify it for sure. What matters most is how parents respond, with understanding, patience, and a willingness to adapt.

Digital Food For Thought

The White Hatter

Facts Not Fear, Facts Not Emotions, Enlighten Not Frighten, Know Tech Not No Tech